Outdated browser

It seems you are using an outdated web browser not supported by this website which may effect your viewing experience.
Please use Edge or any other modern web browser.

Learn more

19 November 2026

Acknowledgments:

  • The remarkable family of Sir Vincent Fairfax, and senior representatives of the Vincent Fairfax Family Foundation.
  • Matt Finnis, CEO of the Cranlana Centre for Ethical Leadership, members of the Cranlana Board, and senior representatives of Monash University.
  • Consul General Jeremy Cornforth, of the US Consulate in Sydney.
  • Major General Mark Ascough and Ms Sheridan Kiernan, the Defence Vincent Fairfax Fellows at Cranlana for 2026.
  • Distinguished guests, fellow military members, veterans, ladies and gentlemen.

I would also like to begin by acknowledging the Traditional Custodians of the land on which we meet – the Gadigal people, and to pay my respects to Elders past and present.

I pay my enduring respects to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander men and women who have served our country, and who continue to serve our country, in times of peace and war.

It is a privilege to deliver this year’s Sir Vincent Fairfax oration. 

My chosen topic this evening is the statement that ‘Our Values are Non-Negotiable’.

Why have I chosen this as my startpoint?  It sounds like an obvious truth.

I could be standing here as the CEO of any business.  But, I’m standing here as the Chief of the Australian Army. 

Of course our values should be non-negotiable. 

We hold the authority, and therefore the responsibility, to take life in defence of the nation, and on behalf of the state.

This is a profound duty, one that obviously demands the highest standards of judgement and behaviour.

But the reality is that this view is not universally held, neither across the world nor here in Australia.

Some believe that there should be no rulebook in war.

That the only things that matter are power and violence. 

Or that we don’t need a Defence Force until war is imminent.

That any end is justified if it protects a nation’s soldiers, or leads to a form of victory.

If you doubt this, let me read you a slice of public commentary against one of our Army ethics videos on YouTube.

I quote: 

‘Our enemies don’t think like this, neither should we … there are no rules anymore’.

‘Nothing can prepare us for the terror that awaits on the battlefield, the monsters men become is inevitable, the cold reality is that much of it is required’.

‘I’m sorry, but there are no rules in war ultimately’.

My aim tonight is to explain why views like these are misguided and unhelpful.

Why Defence Values – and the rules that underpin them – must be non-negotiable … if we are to defend our nation, safeguard our soldiers, and maintain legitimacy as an Army.

I don’t do this to be combative, or to suggest their views don’t matter. 

I wish I could sit down with those commentators and persuade them otherwise. 

But I can’t. 

And so this address offers the next best thing … a chance to make the argument as to why the Army must be committed to our values, in peace and – equally importantly – in war.

I’ll do this in three stages. 

I will invest most of my time making the argument for Defence Values.  My plan is to be persuasive!  You should leave with no doubt.

I will then explain what we are doing in the Australian Army to reinforce our values. 

Finally, I will conclude with some wisdom from Sir Vincent Fairfax himself … an appropriate close, given the event and this impressive audience.

I’ll start with the nature of war itself. 

This is our first, and perhaps most important challenge.

The hard truth is that war has always been a tragic reality of the human condition.

War has existed for as long as civilisation itself, and it has always been brutal.

Indeed, it is fair to argue that brutality is hardwired into war: that the power to corrupt human behaviour is part of its very nature.

I am yet to find any example of war where this isn’t true … where brutality is absent, and where human behaviour has been uncorrupted.

History shows that war has always drawn out the very worst in humanity – from the massacre of the Melians by the Athenians, to the Crusades, to the butchery of the baggage trains at Agincourt, and to My Lai in Vietnam.

The great military strategist Carl von Clausewitz captured war’s nature perfectly when he described it as a ‘blind natural force … composed of primordial violence, hatred and enmity’.

This is the reality we must prepare Australia’s soldiers for.  And I assure you, we are.

It is not enough to train them physically, or just to give them the weapons to fight … we must prepare them ethically and spiritually as well.

We must give them the moral armour to stand firm against war’s corrupting nature.

This gives them the very best chance to come home from war proud of what they have done, able to hold their heads high in society.

Defence Values are the steel plate behind this moral armour. 

Our first value of ‘service’ makes sure that our soldiers put their mission, their mates and the nation above themselves. 

Selfishness has no place on the battlefield, or in the barracks.  Ever.

‘Courage’ come next, which we teach to be as much moral as it is physical. 

Many of our soldiers will need to show physical courage in war, but I guarantee they will all need to show moral courage. 

Courage has a voice as well: the courage to say no, to speak up.

Moral courage is possible, even in the face of a world war.  Let me give you a brief example.

In the battle of Bardia in North Africa in 1941, a young, slim Australian officer called Lieutenant Charles MacFarlane was second in command of an infantry company in the 2/7th Battalion.

His men were rounding up prisoners towards the end of the battle when an Italian soldier popped out of a trench, shot the company commander through the chest, dropped his rifle and raised his hands … reportedly grinning.

An Australian soldier killed the Italian in anger. 

The soldiers, enraged, then moved to bayonet the remaining prisoners – to take revenge.

MacFarlane was the only officer left in the company.  He stepped forward, and ordered them to stop. 

He was obeyed, despite the red mists of anger and revenge.

Lieutenant MacFarlane’s moral courage had a voice that day.  It had authority.  And it was heard. A sliding door moment that could have gone another way. 

Defence’s third value of ‘Respect’ is about understanding the inherent value of human life. 

Yes, we are prepared to take life in the defence of the nation … if we must. But we know that every life has value, and this value must be respected. 

Taking life comes at a cost.  We measure, minimise and then accept that cost with great care. 

Just as Lieutenant MacFarlane did.

‘Integrity’ – the fourth value – means having strong moral principles in the face of unrelenting pressure: a consistent and undivided strength of character.

And the last but not least of our values is ‘excellence’.  This means we strive every day to be masters of our profession. 

This is far more than any moment in time - it must be a lifetime of commitment. 

Our values protect our soldiers against war’s nature … if they are deeply embedded into their character. 

Our Defence Values are non-negotiable.

One does not need to look far to see what war without values looks like.

Simply look at Russia’s actions in Ukraine. 

The deliberate targeting of civilians with long-range strikes.  Widespread and systemic torturing and mistreatment of Ukrainian prisoners of war. 

More than 3,000 coordinated attacks on Ukrainian medical facilities in the last five years. 

Nietzsche once wrote that ‘he who fights with monsters should look to it that he himself does not become a monster’.

We must never abandon our values, or willingly lower ourselves to the standards of those who do not hold them. 

To do so would be like taking off our moral armour against war’s corrupting nature. 

The scars of this can cut deep – scars that are then inevitably carried by our soldiers when they return home.  Scars that can and must be avoided.

The second reason that our values must be non-negotiable is a more pragmatic one.

It is simply in our national interest, our legitimacy as a Defence Force. 

As a middle power, Australia has benefitted immeasurably from the system of global rules and norms that developed after the Second World War.

The outlawing of aggression between nations, the laws governing the use of weapons of war, the creation of treaty frameworks, international arbitration, trade regulation, and nuclear arms control.

All of these created a system where Australia could navigate challenges on a reasoned playing field, with little fear of brute coercion or aggression.

Thanks to these benefits, Australia has invested heavily in supporting and shaping this system of rules and norms over the decades.

Australians were prominent in the drafting of the UN Charter, and we were presiding over the UN General Assembly when it adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948.

We supplied some of the first-ever military peacekeepers into the Netherlands East Indies (now Indonesia) in 1947, and have been major contributors to peacekeeping ever since.

In 1985 we formed the ‘Australia Group’, an informal forum of small and middle powers which fights to this day to stop the spread of chemical and biological weapons.

And in 2002 we ratified the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, writing the ICC crimes into our domestic Criminal Code as Division 268.

It is worth noting that some of this investment only became possible thanks to the sacrifice of Australia’s soldiers.

Prime Minister William ‘Billy’ Hughes was only able to sign the Treaty of Versailles – one of the first diplomatic acts of Australia as an independent nation – after he argued that he spoke for the 60,000 Australian dead.

In many ways, Australia’s position and influence in the world is built on this long-standing commitment to global rules and norms … 

To us being a good international citizen, underpinned by our strong set of national values.

To investing, as the great Australian scholar Hedley Bull put it, at ‘purposes beyond ourselves’.

We are trusted in our region – neighbours by geography, friends by choice. 

We are respected on the world stage, and are often able to bridge rifts between nations.

But nowhere do we potentially gain more from these rules and norms than in the conduct of war.

The rules protect our soldiers from the worst outrages. 

From agonising death at the hands of chemical and biological weapons. 

From torture and mistreatment as prisoners of war. 

From the horrors of nuclear attack.

Again, one does not have to look far to see the implications of war without rules. 

In the First World War, 16,000 Australians were casualties of mustard gas. Most survived, carrying horrendous wounds for the rest of their lives.

22,000 Australians were captured by the Imperial Japanese in World War Two. Over 8,000 – one in three – died from torture and mistreatment when the Geneva Conventions were discarded.

The rules of war only stand when all nations agree to abide by them … what is known as the spirit of reciprocity.

If we want other nations to stick to the rules, then we must do so ourselves.

Not just as a nation on the diplomatic stage, but in the actions of each individual soldier, sailor and aviator in the fight.  Every day.

Again, this is where Defence Values matter.  They guide our actions in the heat of battle.  They keep us on the right side of the standard.  They demand the same of our enemies.

They guard humanity collectively from atrocity.

The third and final reason our values must be non-negotiable lies in the future of warfare.

The pace of technological change in the character of warfare today is profound.

In our estimation, it is the fastest it has been since at least the industrial revolution.

Such a pace of change is highly unusual outside of a world war.

The lightening advances in AI, autonomy and robotics are amongst the most significant.

There is the potential that – for the first time – non-human agents could make truly independent decisions about killing humans on behalf of a state.

This evolution – combined with the rapid degradation in our security environment – is presenting us with new, urgent ethical decisions that we have not had to answer before.

This is not a future problem.  Autonomy and AI are demanding answers now. 

Drones in Ukraine are already using AI to control what we call ‘terminal guidance’: the last moments of a strike where the potential for electronic disruption is most severe.

AI tools are fusing drone, satellite and cyber intelligence to select targets for strike today.

Less than three weeks ago, Ukraine reportedly sent at least 28 armed robots into an assault against Russian positions.  No actual soldiers physically took part in the attack.

Artificially-intelligent, autonomous robots are a reality of war right now … not some vision of the future.

It falls in no small part to our men and women in uniform to make decisions about the moral appetite to use these systems.

Our soldiers will certainly bear the outcomes of those decisions, whatever the outcome.

What should help guide us?  The answer is simple.  Our values.

Our values must underpin every consideration we make on including autonomy and AI in our ‘kill chains’ (as we call them), just as they should guide every decision we make about violence.

Our inherent respect for human life should be central when deciding how far we should let non-human agents go in making decisions to kill.

We will need to hold to the courage of our national convictions when considering the morality of technology … rather than just bowing down to the pressures of war or blindly following the example of others.

And … as it always should … integrity should be at the forefront of the professional advice we provide to Government, and to the international community, on these profoundly important matters.

My basic litmus test is … if it is moral, ethical and legal, then we do it.

Can I assure you now that, from a targeting perspective, there will always be a human in the loop.

So, there you have it.  Three arguments as to why our Defence Values are non-negotiable.  The nature of war.  Our national interests.  And the future of warfare.

Are you convinced yet?  We can explore in Q&A if needed.

I’m going to begin to close by speaking briefly on what the Australian Army is doing, to ensure that our values remain at the forefront of our profession.

Some of you may be aware that over the last two years our Army has conducted a significant review of the state of the Army profession, led by my amazing predecessor Lieutenant General Simon Stuart.

This examined the broadest reaches of our profession: our jurisdiction, our expertise and … significantly … our capacity for self-regulation in the face of war’s corrupting nature.

The work began, as it should, at the top … with senior leader accountability, with the accountabilities of the Chief of Army, and with the role of the Army’s Generals.

It culminated with the publication of a new code of honour and conduct for Army Generals, called ‘The Sword and Baton’.

This is a public document, found on the web.  I’m happy to provide copies should you wish.

The ‘Sword and Baton’ codifies in clear and unambiguous terms the professional expectations of an Australian Army General.

You won’t be surprised to hear that our values run through every element of it. 

Service over self.  Moral courage.  Universal respect, founded on humility. 

Professional integrity, tied to inescapable accountability for our Army as an institution.

An expectation of honourable resignation, offered in the face of intolerable failure.

Every General must now agree to adhere to this code before they accept the insignia and sword of their position … before they receive their mameluke sword, before they take on their appointment as a General.

I make the same commitment to the CDF, and ultimately to the Governor General. I am accountable for the 44,797 soldiers I lead today.

There can certainly now be no doubt as to what society should expect from its Generals, what the Army expects of us, and what we expect and demand from each other.

Our next action was to strengthen the foundation of our profession … the soldier.

Army’s senior leaders came to the view that the identity of the soldier had become blurred over the years … 

Disconnected from the profession, and from its core role as the nation’s expert in land combat.

We sought to address this through a second publication, called simply ‘The Soldier’. 

Written firmly in the context of war and the battlefield, this codifies a soldier’s duty.

The need to train hard, in the relentless pursuit of professional excellence.

To prepare for the rigours and dangers of combat, in the mind as much as in the body.

To accept a profound contract of unlimited liability to the nation.

To commit to the inherent value of mateship. 

To look out for one another, to protect and support each other, especially when times are tough.

Again, our values are articulated as non-negotiable within ‘The Soldier’.

A soldier cannot demonstrate integrity half-heartedly.  Courage … moral and physical … is not optional in war … or in peace. 

Professional excellence is not a corporate slogan – it is what keeps you and your mates alive in battle.

One of my favourite parts of ‘The Soldier’ is where WO2 Tommy Munyarrun, an indigenous soldier of more than 30 years, explains the difference between a warrior and a soldier.

‘Every soldier is a warrior’, Tommy explains, ‘but not every warrior is a soldier. 

A soldier lives by a code and serves a higher purpose; there are many warriors who do not’.

This is a wonderful example, borne from our country’s oldest culture, of how our values hold us to a higher standard as professionals.

But only when they are non-negotiable.

These publications are good, and the words in them matter.  But words can only go so far.

We have to ensure our soldiers believe in our values, from Recruit to our Generals.

We do this by teaching, mentoring and leading, day in day out, across the curriculum of the Army and ADF profession.

Every recruit and officer cadet now receives a copy of ‘The Soldier’ on their bunk the first night they arrive in training.

Feedback is that the book is becoming a centreline for our newest professionals … something to read, mull on and absorb throughout a career.

Every General receives a copy of ‘The Sword and Baton’ on the day of their promotion, signed by me as the Chief.

This is how we are ensuring our values are hardwired throughout the Army, from top to bottom, today and into the future.

I promised at the outset to finish with some wisdom from Sir Vincent Fairfax himself.

But I’ll do so reflecting on a demographic that is sometimes under-represented in our reflections on the Army profession … our veterans.

Just over four months into my tenure, I now end all of my formal communications with the phrase ‘Team Army – Soldiers for Life’.

This is no idle phrase.  It reflects my intention to widen our Army’s embrace, and to hold our veteran community closer.

To acknowledge our families who also serve as they support us, long after the uniform is no longer worn.

There are more than a 400,000 Australians alive today who have worn our Army’s uniform.

Many of these are veterans of the Vietnam War.  But increasingly our youngest veterans are from Australia’s longest war … Afghanistan.

All veterans had the courage to sign the contract of unlimited liability … to be ready to fight and if necessary die in defence of our nation.

Some gave their tomorrow for our today.

Soldiering does change you. 

Once you have been a soldier, you can of course return to being a citizen … but you never really return to being a civilian. 

You are a soldier always.

Demonstrating the courage to serve means that the Army … and indeed the nation … carries an enduring obligation to respect and care for our veterans.

We tend to focus on doing this physically. But caring for their spirits and their souls and their families is – in my humble opinion – just as important.

We must do all we can to help our veterans to feel pride in their service … to ensure that their Army service remains a positive influence in their lives as they grow older and wiser.

I want our Army’s veterans to be proud of the current generation of diggers: of the way in which we are stewarding their inheritance in a challenging world.

And importantly, I want the Army to stand up and support those veterans who have the courage to speak up for – and defend – our values. 

They should not feel alone when they do so.

Sir Vincent Fairfax said at the opening of the Birthright Conference in 1983, ‘let us remember that the power and wealth of a democracy is measured not only by the number and quality of its eminent leaders, but by thousands of ‘little’ leaders who provide its real strength’.

It is my enduring hope as the Chief of the Army that our almost 45,000 ‘little leaders’ in uniform, alongside the 400,000 ‘little leaders’ who have worn our uniform in the past, remain a positive strength in our democracy.

Be assured we will do our part to make sure this is true … with their moral armour firmly held in place by the steel plate of Defence Values.

Team Army.  Soldiers for Life.

Thank you.

Details

Issuer

Location